Talk:Jeanne D'Arc/@comment-213.104.15.218-20151026161900/@comment-26158367-20151028164309

In the long run, Atalanta is more preferable, no counter arguments given here. Definitely try to get her.

For me, Jeanne D'Arc was (no pun intended) a Godsend. With no H-buffers, I could do Intermediate EH okay, but they could die fast. With Jeanne, that won't be a problem anymore. She also makes it possible for me to (more easily) get Sacred Light II... So, I'm definitely not too mad to have two Jeannes now. My Light materials were rotting anyway. (Still are. Bring Light FAWs, Nubee!) My Atalanta, btw, is currently rotting because I have nothing to bring her potential out.

Sure, Jeanne's skill is subpar compared to other options. She will probably lose her usefulness at some point. But right now, at my current stage, Jeanne definitely was who I needed more, because she's the only option readily available. So I agree with the above person that to pass final judgement on a card's usefulness, the other available cards of the individual player should be considered...

tldr; If you don't get Atalanta through T.O. but lack a proper set of Light buffers, it shouldn't be the end of the world.